Welcome to the Chronicles of
The McHenry "Manson Family"
Everything on this page is published with express permission of the author. No information on this site is private or confidential. Opinions expressed in Steve Manson's letters do not reflect the opinions or views of the authors of this page. This page is used to raise awareness of mental health, self-defense, child grooming, human trafficking, and keeping communities safe from the toxicity perpetuated by the prison system. Any likenesses to names or faces found to be offensive are entirely coincidental, or protected free speech because it is public information and verifiable truth. The statements in this document are not to be taken as accusations, hearsay, deceit, harassment, or anything but protected free speech of an educational and biographical nature. None of this document is intended to distress, defame, harass, discredit, or promote hearsay about any individuals. The purpose of this document is to shed light on truth to keep the story from being swept under the rug, as requested by Joanne Manson.
Everything on this site is a work in progress. Please bare with us while documents are sorted, sources are verified, and proper legal procedure is pursued so as not to disclose anything which poses a risk to victims/survivors of the undue grief begotten by the McHenry's own Manson Family Circus. As well as anything which violates the privacy rights of this man who relentlessly violates other people's rights. If you have suggestions, contributions, media, or corrections please submit feedback to the email at the bottom of this page, thank you!
McHenry's Own Mansons,
Mr. Manson is a man who was convicted of a number of felonies who served time at Menard CC, among many other correctional facilities. He was sentenced twice what he served, but served ten years in prison for his fifth DUI. However, he admits in his own letters that he is a deeply damaged and disturbed individual. Despite years of incarceration, he remains undomesticated, with a tendency to act uncivil toward people who upset him, and a self-proclaimed intolerance for authority.
A Summary Timeline:
Steve Manson's Relentless Requests:
Steve Manson
sent hundreds of letters from prison, an overwhelming amount. The few letters sent in reply were returned by being tsunami'd by the media he submitted. Besides the mountain of letters was also checks or money orders (which were given to Joanne Manson), disgusting pornographic images (which were destroyed), and random moody diatribes. His former neighbors criticized him for his violently erratic behavior and said he might stop being "abused" so much if he cooperated a little. Steve in turn wrote that he wanted to "piss off those fuckers until they move me through every correctional facility in the state!" Fully intending on giving his captors the hardest time he could muster.
Steve's Mother and The Origin of This "Blog" Effort
While Steve was in Prison his mother, Joanne, had to take care of the family home and the massive mess he left behind. She employed the neighbor's children to do yard work once in a while, and they helped her clean out the garage of all the things Steve had left in there. One editor of this blog still has the bicycle given to him twelve years prior. After remodeling some, moving out, and renting the house to in-laws, Joanne Manson began receiving letters from Steve, demanding she produce an autobiographical web publication to "make him famous" for alleged abuse he suffered at Menard. This is where the editors of this blog come in, as we were specifically hired and employed to publish anything we can find that will promote True aspects of Steve's life story. Not only was permission given, but we were explicitly instructed before Joanne died to get this word out there, to not falsify anything, and to only expand on real events pertaining to Steve and his son's life.
Steve's grandmother, Marie, died at the age of 101, locked in a room, completely isolated from all of her family, and all of her savings and income used up by Steve. Instead of allowing professionals to care for his grandmother in failing health, Steve took it upon himself to do so. Subjecting his son's wife children to the trauma of caring for her and watching her die has been a 'bonding experience' for their new family. It appears a possibility that nobody but Steve and his son got any inheritance after completely alienating their entire family from her.
It is alleged that Steve Manson may have even falsified documents to re-write his mother's will [7] by effectively holding her hostage while she was afflicted with cancers affecting her brain. By changing the will while she was of unsound mind, all of Joanne Manson's siblings, children, and grandchildren were explicitly omitted from any inheritance. His sister, who was formerly executor of his mother's estate, was omitted entirely. There was at least one investigation and criminal case regarding the illegal hijacking of Joanne Manson's estate, her credit cards, her bank accounts, material possessions, etc., but details have been intentionally obfuscated by the perpetrators to avoid accountability. Due to constant harassment and misinformation, the entire family appears oblivious to the full extent they've been possibly robbed. Both Joanne and her Mother died isolated, alienated, and rejected by all of their family except Steve due to rumors and immoral actions allegedly done by him and his son. Before Steve left prison, his sister was executor of his mother's estate and his brother was to inherit property because Steven Jr. can't live near child care facilities—after he left prison, he ended up with everything. The property continues to be decimated, neighbors report mouse infestations due to how unsavory conditions have gotten in and around the area due to the accumulation of garbage.
Steve and his son are proud political "anti-vaxxers", even boasting a tall "Fuck Joe Biden and Fuck You for Voting for Him" flag in their Antioch yard for a time. Joanne died of complications brought on by COVID-19, just days before she was due to get cancer treatment. Her mother had beaten COVID at least 3 times before succumbing to natural causes in a very unnatural environment.
It is publicly known and publicly available information that Steven M. Manson, "Steve Jr." is the son of Steven L. Manson and he is a registered child predator and convicted child sex predator who was sentenced to twenty years in prison, but served ten years for several crimes. Crimes including the rape of a minor, and forced sexual favors from another woman.
Steven Jr. currently claims to take care of his wife's two children by doing scrap work to get money under the table while still receiving public assistance(his business cards are available). He has driven a wedge between his wife and her family, testifying against his mother-in-law when she stopped by to give her daughter her father's ashes. He specifically finds the line of work where he is able to drive around to stalk children. Having spent nights out until 2a.m., until he got a revoked license, and drove at least 29mph over the speed limit, forcing him to use a child as his chauffer. They've bragged about stealing anything they can out of people's lawns, as well as from the garbage company, but no proof has come up yet beyond complains from people whose possessions have already been scrapped. According to his public prison profile he has a white supremacist tattoo, and a nazi tattoo, a confederate skull, nazi 'SS' lightning bolts, and several other tattoos.
One charge Steve Jr. went to prison for was the rape of a thirteen year old girl who he manipulated into doing everything he asked, during, and after. By using the thirteen year old girl's infatuation with him as a 20-year-old man he created insurmountable friction within her family. With calculated antagonism, the Manson family destroyed the victim's family, inflicting irreparable psychological damage. After going to prison, while convicted of being a child sex predator and serving time in prison, and working around the system in place to prevent manipulation of a victim, Steve Jr.'s victim was continuously manipulated.
With contact by proxy, and other methods of circumventing procedure in place to protect victims from being manipulated by their rapists, Steven Jr. remained in contact with his victim as she grew up. Eventually Steven Jr. coerced her into having the court relinquish her automatic order of protection when she turned eighteen. The warden still refused to allow visitation of a predator with his victim. In order to overrule the relinquished protection, the judge ordered visitation block.
Steve Jr.'s Mother, Karen T., who worked as a correctional officer at the local department of corrections at the time, took the victim across state lines to a servicer in Missouri who was willing to do an over-the-phone wedding to Steve Jr. Being wedded to his victim, he was then able to control her life entirely from prison. She eventually divorced him.
Steve Jr. moved to Antioch and it is documented and well known in several recordings and documents, texts, emails, police reports, that he allegedly harasses all his neighbors, passerbys, and anyone he can in the community, even screaming racial slurs at children. He intentionally plays his music loud to antagonize anyone in earshot.
Steve Jr's Wife's two children are frequently under the "care" of people described by their own family as "criminal monsters" who have a tendency to manipulate and groom whoever they can. He testified in court that the mother does not live at the same address as the small child he is currently grooming, while also reporting to DCSF that she does live there, because otherwise it would mean the child is left alone in the care of a person with a history as a violent felon.
It is alleged that Steve uses the elder daughter to drive him from place to place, manipulating her by screaming at her and rewarding her. It is not an exaggeration to say it is textbook grooming. In fact, the actions are textbook psychological manipulation tactics typically used by people with manipulative personality disorders. Steve uses the children in order to get Housing assistance, LIHEAP, food stamps, donations, and to manipulate the police by telling them what to say to them. Having been accused of allegedly being sexually inappropriate with his own blood family member, there is no telling what Steve Sr. is capable of. Besides that he raised his own son to commit such heinous acts of cruelty against humanity as a convicted child sex offender, and child sex predator.
Sex Offenders have developed an extralegal scheme used to trick law enforcement, with moving in one address while claiming to live at another, using a third to avoid legal accountability. In Steven Jr's case this involves petitioning the court to allow him to move to a community or area outside of the state where sex offenders already live, reporting to law enforcement that he is actually residing at a Hotel or other short-term residency, and then residing in the actual property or home that you live in. Steven M. Manson has the benefit of his father's property as a fourth venue with which to do business out of, under an alias. The crime potential is exponential to how many places a registered sex offender can claim to reside. (Please talk to your lawmakers about this, this is a serious epidemic plaguing America, and it means the nation's children are not safe. This information is public in order to keep you and your loved ones safe from malicious predators like these.)
Since being released from Parole, Steven Jr has been involved in several civil, criminal, and traffic cases:
McHenry County:
2022 CF 170 (Johnsburg/ 2 theft charges/stole from dying grandma)
2022 CF 189 (McHenry/ 8 theft charges/stole from dying grandma)
2023 TR 4969 (McH county / seat belt violation)
2023 TR 5236 (spring grove / driving 21-25 above)
2023 MT 1083 (McHenry/revoked and speeding 26-35 above)
2023 CF 767 (Lakewood/6 counts involving accident with injury)
Lake County:
22 CM 332 3-28-22 (Criminal damage)
22 MT 4925 9-16-22 (Major traffic)
22 CM 1629 12-14-22 (disorderly conduct)
22 OV 1232 12-28-22 (Open Burning)
23 CH 40 3-6-23 ( Chancery/Injuction)
23 OV 507 5-30-23 ( Open Burning)
23 OV 642 7-14-23 ( Open Burning (impersonating father @ son’s residence)
23 OP 1698 8-2-23 (SNCO)
Steve's Ex-Wife and Steve Jr's First Wife
Steve's ex-wife worked as a correctional officer for the McHenry department of corrections. Steven Jr. married his first wife by proxy through this woman. When it was not legally allowed to visitation because she was a rape victim as a minor who was groomed, it was Steve's ex-wife who intervened by driving the victim out of state and convincing her to marry Steven Jr. over the phone while he was in prison for raping her when she was 13.
The Mansons continues to harass, stalk, and attack her online. On February 1st, Steven L. Manson, with the alias "Mark Walker" slandered her with phone calls, online postings, and other means of denigrating her character in attempt to get her fired.
Steve's Grandmother
Steve's grandmother, Marie, lived to be 101 years old—that is to say, she lived well and held on strong while her daughter cared for her. When her daughter died of COVID-19, as Steve Manson consolidated control over her estate, she was left in her grandson's care, and didn't quite make it very long. She suffered several bouts with COVID-19 as she was subject to the care of anti-vaxxers who live very hectically and uncleanly. It is impossible to say she died peacefully while her grandson and great grandson waged war with everyone around them.
The Manson Family Still Seems Dangerous
As soon as they were let off parole, the Manson family stopped pretending to be polite (they are admittedly not good actors either though, the ruckus they caused before this point is hard to overstate, with several court cases on record for inappropriate and uncivil behavior). They set illegal fires, burn chemicals, burn tall flames, and have set fires to the side of their neighbor's house. Allegedly they have set fire to their garage in Antioch for insurance purposes, allegedly set fire to a McHenry motorcycle, and a family member's vehicle. The insurance payout probably even enabled them to pursue more adventurous misadventures.
Together, the family apparently deceived Buss Ford Lincoln Mercury of McHenry into loaning them a truck, with which they allow Steve, with a revoked license, and his teenaged granddaughter in-law to drive. They've allegedly been in multiple hit and run accidents, even resorting to using a spare tire after destroying the right rear tire of their white F150. The damage to the vehicle did not stop them from towing a trailer and overloading frequently. The damage done by them in the vehicle has yet to be fully reported by the victims of property damage in their alleged hit-and-runs.
On Easter of 2023 Steve Jr. threatened his wife, saying "you're gonna die", and Steve threatened to abduct her children, saying "you'll never get those kids". Jr's wife screamed her daughter's name and said to call the cops. Steve screamed back "go ahead and call the cops" and the police were called by concerned neighbors. The cops emboldened them more than they helped the situation at all. Steve told them to get off his property and they obliged, permitting him to abduct children he has no blood relation to on Easter while his daughter in law fled the scene. They continue to threaten and harass their neighbors.
They spent all of Autism awareness month specifically targeting autistic people to terrorize and bully, seemingly just to promote suffering, using flood lights, loud music, banging, clanging, encouraging dog barking, screaming, and threatening(see the youtube playlist yourself). Besides banging, screaming, clashing, and acting obnoxious in their front yard, they have high-intensity halogen lights they face toward the windows of autistic neighbors. The police are unequipped to deal with them, by sidestepping the law and lying to the police they never get caught. Criminals are too slick to be caught in the act of violating the basic human rights of everyone around them; the guilty don't feel guilty, they learn not to.
On June 22nd Steve Manson was arrested for driving on a revoked license as he is frequently wont to do. In attempt to obstruct the towing of the vehicle, the arrest, and efforts of the officers Amber N. Manson screamed in their faces, drove recklessly, instructed her child to flee, and was arrested after a few moments of struggle and resisting. Their time away from their house has been the only peace the Lakeland neighborhood has known since Mr. Manson's release.
The peace was short lived upon Mr Manson's return, as he blared incredibly loud music, lights, noises, and pacing around his yard like a violent primal being whenever he is seen. Aggressing, threatening, menacing, harassing, and antagonizing everyone who falls in his gaze.
Antagonizing the Neighbors
(A sign taped the to the front door of the home of Jennifer McLegggan, who is Black and says she fears for her life due to racial animus in her neighborhood, July 13, 2020, in Valley Stream, N.Y.)
On November 7th Steven Jr. arrived with his wife, Amber Kennedy and Dezerae Kennedy at his father's house to apparently dump more garbage and to sell an appliance. While unloading his trailer the disabled navy vet's daughter across the street was trying to talk to her friend so Steven Jr. began muttering all sorts of heinous threats while telling his wife's daughter to surveil and record them.
Later a white truck arrived and waited for an hour before hauling a washing machine and leaving. The Mansons scrapping business is still operational as of November 8th.
In 2004 Steve tried to give his neighbor hardcore pornography for their thirteenth birthday in attempt to groom them, the kid was shook and refused to take any of it. He had very frequently employed neighbor children to do work for him. Often intoxicated at the time, he would offer to take neighbor kids for joy rides, show off his weapons collection, and get very close and friendly with children. Firing potatoes at random houses from a potato gun. At the same time, Steve was extremely hostile to anybody who got too close to him. One time he had the neighbor kid wipe his hardrive clean and then Steve ripped it out of the computer and threw it into the drainage ditch for fear of getting caught for the crimes he was committing.
At one point pipe bombs were discovered and detonated on Joanne Manson's family property, where Steven still lives at.
The McHenry bomb squad had to make a house call, and blockaded the neighborhood to incoming traffic in order to safely discharge the explosives. "Whoever" planted the bombs was never discovered, however. Common sense points to Steve, the guy who threatened to do so in the first place, but it's so unbelievable he never was found guilty of allegedly planting bombs on his own mother's property.
Not very tech-savvy, Steve once employed his neighbor to sell a broken icecream truck on ebay, claiming he was married to her to the customer. When the icecream truck was delivered and immediately broke. This led to the neighbor getting banned from the website entirely and disallowed from making a new account. He later renovated an icecream truck in order to sell drugs out of it.
They don't need drugs to act crazy, but they are known to allegedly indulge in a variety of different substances, legal or not—for a time they sold "Spice", the synthetic marijuana, wherever they could, until supplies ran out. Having family who own and work for a restaurant in Crystal Lake, Steve was able to stock ice-cream for an alibi and use ice-cream trucks to sell drugs. Typically he would sell to the same demographic as neighborhood children who want ice-cream, and offer teenagers dope and other things. One incident involved him calling the police on young men who robbed him while doing so, but they in turn confessed they didn't steal money, but drugs from Mr. Manson and all parties involved were implicated in the criminal activity.
Later he got into trouble with the law, was arrested several times and implicated in numerous crimes. Steve had antagonized some local criminals at some point who then went to his house and confronted him. When he went outside to fight them they beat him in the lawn with a baseball bat until he was immobile. He has claimed to have suffered brain damage from the experience. It's possible the trauma has intensified his impulse control and personality since the event, but he has been consistently into underground activities.
Around 2006, Steven L. Manson was charged for repeatedly driving while intoxicated with a revoked license and sentenced to two years in prison.
It has come to light that Steve has had orders of protection placed against him upon the revelation that he had sexually assaulted his blood relative and other women when they were under his care as children. Alleged in these orders was sexual favors, drugging, coercion, violence, threats, harassment, threatening to deprive a mother of her children, threatening to plant drugs, sexual threats, homoerotic fantasies, and the list goes on.
Due to his manipulative nature, his victims moved and changed addresses, the threat only became unsubstantiated when Steve stopped being able to stalk and harass his victim, thus the order(s) of protection were dismissed. Steven continues to harass whoever he can as long as he can get away with it.
Steve's Siblings
Steven's brother Gary Manson was driven to suicide. Seemingly by the combination of grief over the passing of his daughter and mother, and harassment following the siege of the Manson family household. Steve celebrates his own brother's death, even saying he's "glad he is dead." Allegedly he committed suicide, suspiciously immediately after his brother claims to have found out he worked as a police informant for the Crystal Lake police department. The timing is interesting to say the least.
We will not go into details of Steve's sisters or their families because a great deal of effort has gone into defaming and harassing them to coerce them into complicity with Stevens' criminal actions as possible by Steve Manson. If there are rumors about Steve Manson's siblings, they may have originated from Steve himself. What is certain is that Steve has violated their human rights as much as he can get away with without getting caught, or by lying under oath in order to escape charges. Let it be known that there exists testimony, witness reports, documents, letters written by Steve, and other evidence alleging Steve's sexual indecency toward women and children has been nothing short of barbaric.
Previous images have been redacted and replaced with new scans provided by the circuit clerk.
It is legal to post information about public-record court documents online.[10]
The fact remains: Abuse occurred, instigated by a Manson family member—Against a Manson family member, against the community, and against the court system.
It should also be noted that if his family had not enabled him, funded him, provided him resources, a home to stay, refusing to protect Steve's mother from Steve, and come forward with their allegations, then a long string of abuse, felonious crimes against humanity, deaths, and several rapes would not have happened. The sister of one blog author would not have been drugged and raped by Steve. Steve's abused could have been nipped in the bud decades ago, but his family chooses instead to sweep his abuse under the rug. Even going so far as to sue contributors to this blog effort in order to deprive them of their first amendment rights, as well as attempting to disarm them in the face of violent threats from the Steves Manson. While smeared by Steve and his heinous actions, still the entire family has yet to prove him wrong about them or that they are not entirely comprised of self-serving petite-bourgeoisie hatemongers akin to Charle's Manson's "Family". Robbing the community, obfuscating the courts, and letting their demon kin run amok, stymieing every effort to expose the reality for what it is, trying instead to save imaginary face about the family trait of an inflated ego.
Steve Manson's Autobiographical letters from prison: https://menardcc.blogspot.com/2019/12/my-true-story-at-menard-cc-to-date.html
Youtube Playlist With Some Interactions With Steve:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bvioTeZWVv4&list=PLKPeLWVgF1hJNdonODszlHdVofKWnPMZM
Manson Criminal Offenses Public Information:
Registered Sex Offender, Steven Jr. https://isp.illinois.gov/Sor/Details/X19A1630
Sex Offender Public Notice: https://lakecountygazette.com/stories/610070065 -steven-m-manson-living-in-antioch-a-registered-sex-offender-as-of-oct-26
News Release: https://www.shawlocal.com/2012/01/05/man-gets-same-sentence-as-father-20-years/acnsanq/
https://www.shawlocal.com/northwest-herald/2023/08/19/mchenry-county-felony-report-for-week-of-aug-6-12-2023/
Release information: https://mchenrytimes.com/stories/574867287-25-inmates-sentenced-in-mchenry-county-to-be-released-from-illinois-department-of-corrections-during-q1
Charged 20 years for aggravated intimidation and DUI: https://mchenrycountyblog.com/2011/08/15/20-years-for-aggravated-intimidtion-and-dui-felonies/
Steve M. Manson's Public Record in IL Available, Search:
"Manson, Steven L"
and
"Manson, Steven M"
Lake County:
https://circuitclerk.lakecountyil.gov/publicAccess/html/common/index.xhtml
McHenry County:
https://caseinfo.mchenrycountyil.gov/pca
Contributors to This Blog:
August Dietzgen, John S. Turkin, J.H. Biegle, Jessica Arbunkle, John D Reed, Ybeunk Mainlander, Harry Reed, Kerry Fogle, Alexandra Eastdroop, Jeremiah Ritter, Amber Manson, the Actual Satan, Steven Manson, Dezerae K.,Qemal Stafa, Riley Loveshade, Emma Goldman, Kurt Boyle, Jan Nexhmije, Karen Taylor, Brianna Manson, Katherine Esser, Svetlana Pavlechenko, Sarah Schmidt, and Pensylvester McBlumpkin, No Relation.
You can contact our team at ybeunkmainlander@gmail.com
Permission to Publish Autobiographical Details about the Manson Family for the Educational Purpose of Raising Awareness Expressly Given by Joanne Manson, Rest in Peace.
Definitions:
LEGALITY AND DEFINITIONS:
All information, pictures, video, media, and footage is provided for EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. No media contained within this playlist may be used to defame, harass, ridicule, or attack any individuals, their identities, or lifestyle. Any names or information is publicly available, and not property to any private persons.
DOMESTIC TERRORISM "is generally defined by law as involving criminal acts dangerous to human life on U.S. soil that appear intended to coerce a civilian population or influence or affect the conduct of government." The intimidation of citizens, police officers, and household with the objective of manipulation, coercion, or to promote action or inaction among those members is the definition of DOMESTIC TERRORISM.
PSYCHOPATH is generally defined by law as someone who is delusional, or experiencing a form of Psychosis not limited to: Groupthink, Mob-Mentality, Group Psychosis, Hallucinations, Ideological Delusions, etc.
GROOMING the act of deliberately establishing a relationship with a child to prepare them for abuse.
PREDATOR a person who has been convicted of a criminal offense against a victim who is a minor as defined by the law.
CONSENT permission for something to happen or agreement to do something. The law defines that a Minor does not have the developmental capacity to give consent, and this fact is inarguable.
RACISM Racism is prejudice or irrational hate against any nationality and/or the anti-scientific belief in the idea of various human populations, ethnicities, nationalities, and groups as separate "races" of the human species.
SUPREMACY-IDEOLOGY the belief that a certain group of people is superior to all others.
HARASSMENT the Law defines Harassment as: Unlawful violence, like assault or battery or stalking, OR. A credible threat of violence, AND. The violence or threats seriously scare, annoy, or harass someone and there is no valid reason for it.
INTIMIDATION an act or course of conduct directed at a specific person to cause that person to fear or apprehend fear.
MOLESTATION to make unwanted or improper sexual advances towards (someone), especially a child.
DRUG a medicine or other substance which has a physiological effect when ingested or otherwise introduced into the body.
It is against the law in several areas for someone with a felony conviction to not disclose the information that they have been convicted of a Felony if the question is raised as to whether they have a felony.
copyleft(É”) all rights reversed
Nothing on this site may be viewed or reproduced for the intent of profit or illegal activity [defamation, hearsay, harassment, abuse, bullying, etc.,] but may otherwise be redistributed freely. This work is the product of group effort and historical circumstance. No individual or incorporated entity may claim ownership of the content on this page or likewise accuse any group, organization, or individual of any ownership or attribution.
Footnotes:
[7] The Will of Joanne M. Manson, Case File "2022WI000113"
[10] The disclosure of information “acquired from non-record sources – such as observation, office emails, discussions with co-workers and the ‘rumor mill’– does not violate the Privacy Act . . . even if the information disclosed is also contained in agency records.” Lambert v. United States at *5 (quoting Cloonan, 768 F. Supp. 2d. at 164); Thompson v. BOP, No. 1:10-CV-00578-JOF, 2012 WL 13072105, at *5 (N.D. Ga. Jan. 20, 2012) (For “a disclosure to be covered by section 552a(b), there must have initially been a retrieval from the system of records which was at some point a source of the information.” (citations omitted)); Savage v. Geren, No. CV-08-S-2189-NE, 2010 WL 11519448, at *13 (N.D. Ala. Nov. 15, 2010) (“[T]he Privacy Act does not prohibit disclosure of information or knowledge obtained from other sources other than ‘records.’...In particular, it does not prevent federal employees or officials from talking – even gossiping – about anything of which they have non-record-based knowledge.” (citations omitted)). . .
. . . A plaintiff has the burden of demonstrating that a “disclosure” by the agency has occurred. See, e.g., Askew v. United States, 680 F.2d 1206, 1209-11 (8th Cir. 1982); Zerilli v. Smith, 656 F.2d 705, 715-16 (D.C. Cir. 1981); Boyd v. United States, 932 F. Supp. 2d 830, 835 (S.D. Ohio 2013); cf. Hernandez v. Johnson, 514 F. App’x 492, 500 (5th Cir. 2013) (holding that “disclosure is not actionable because it identified [plaintiff] only by his first name and neither recipient knew who ‘Jaime’ was”); Luster v. Vilsack, 667 F.3d 1089, 1097-98 (10th Cir. 2011) (rejecting appellant’s contentions that “mere transmission of the documents to a fax machine at which unauthorized persons might have viewed the documents constitutes a prohibited disclosure” and that “the possibility that a record might be revealed to unauthorized readers by negligent or reckless transmission is sufficient to constitute a prohibited disclosure under the Act’”); Whyde v. Rockwell Int’l Corp., 101 F. App’x 997, 1000 (6th Cir. 2004) (“[T]he fact that [a company] somehow came into possession of documents that might have been included in plaintiff’s personnel file . . . gives rise only to a metaphysical doubt as to the existence of a genuine issue of material fact.”); Brown v. Snow, 94 F. App’x 369, 372 (7th Cir. 2004) (ruling that district court grant of summary judgment was proper where no evidence was found that record was disclosed, and stating that “burden is on the plaintiff at the summary judgment stage to come forward with specific evidence”); Lennon v. Rubin, 166 F.3d 6, 10-11 (1st Cir. 1999) (where agency employee testified that, despite memorandum indicating otherwise, she had disclosed information only within agency, and where plaintiff responded that whether his file was reviewed by other individuals is question of fact he “want[ed] decided by a fact finder, ‘not an affidavit,’” finding such “arguments misapprehend [plaintiff’s] burden at the summary judgment stage”); Russell v. Potter, No. 3:08-CV-2272, 2011 WL 1375165, at *9 (N.D. Tex. Mar. 4, 2011) (holding that plaintiff cannot prove disclosure violation where “the only agency involved, the Postal Service, received rather than ‘disclosed’ the information in question”); Collins v. FBI, No. 10-cv-03470, 2011 WL 1627025, at *7 (D.N.J. Apr. 28, 2011) (dismissing claim and stating that plaintiff’s “conclusory allegations” of unlawful disclosure, “without identifying or describing who acted against Plaintiff or what the person did, is insufficient”); Roggio v. FBI, No. 08-4991, 2009 WL 2460780, at *2 (D.N.J. Aug. 11, 2009) (concluding that plaintiffs “fail[ed] to allege sufficient facts supporting that the FBI, as opposed to some other law enforcement body, disclosed [one plaintiff’s] rap sheet” on the Internet, where plaintiffs “base[d] their allegation on . . . the mere fact that [a particular Internet] posting contained some expunged information”), reconsideration denied, No. 08-4991, 2009 WL 2634631 (D.N.J. Aug. 26, 2009); Walia v. Chertoff, No. 06-cv-6587, 2008 WL 5246014, at *11 (E.D.N.Y. Dec. 17, 2008) (concluding that plaintiff failed to make out prima facie case under subsection (b) of Privacy Act because plaintiff alleged merely that records were accessible to other individuals in office, rather than that they were actually disclosed); Buckles v. Indian Health Serv., 310 F. Supp. 2d 1060, 1068 (D.N.D. 2004) (finding that plaintiffs failed to “prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that IHS disclosed protected information” where plaintiffs did not “have personal knowledge that [the memorandum was disclosed]” and witnesses at trial denied disclosing or receiving memorandum); Meldrum v. USPS, No. 5:97CV1482, slip op. at 11 (N.D. Ohio Jan. 21, 1999) (finding lack of evidence that disclosure occurred where plaintiff alleged that, among other things, file had been left in unsecured file cabinet), aff’d per curiam, No. 99-3397, 2000 WL 1477495, at *2 (6th Cir. Sept. 25, 2000). But cf. Speaker, 623 F.3d at 1386 (finding plaintiff’s complaint sufficient to survive summary judgment because he “need not prove his case on the pleadings” but rather “must merely provide enough factual material to raise a reasonable inference, and thus a plausible claim, that the [Ctrs. for Disease Control & Prevention] was the source of the disclosures”); Ciralsky v. CIA, 689 F. Supp. 2d 141, 156-57 (D.D.C. 2010) (concluding that plaintiff’s allegation of CIA disclosure to unidentified government officials, who were unrelated to handling of plaintiff’s case, was “not unacceptably vague” and need not include identities of alleged recipients for CIA to “understand Plaintiff’s charge”); Tolbert-Smith v. Chu, 714 F. Supp. 2d 37, 43 (D.D.C. 2010) (ruling that plaintiff had stated claim for relief under Privacy Act where plaintiff “pled that a member of [agency] management placed records referring and relating to her disability on a server accessible by other federal employees and members of the public”). (RETRIEVED FROM: https://www.justice.gov/opcl/overview-privacy-act-1974-2020-edition/disclosures-third-parties )
Comments
Post a Comment